Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese
This podcast takes a deep dive into the market-moving events to cut through the noise and help you identify what really matters. Facts vs Feelings is hosted by Chief Market Strategist, Ryan Detrick and VP, Global Macro Strategist, Sonu Varghese, and is a product of the Carson Investment Research Team.
The information included herein is for informational purposes and is intended for use by advisors only, and should not be copied, reproduced, or re-distributed without the consent of CWM, LLC. Carson Partners offers investment advisory services through CWM, LLC, an SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Carson Coaching and CWM, LLC are separate but affiliated companies and wholly-owned subsidiaries of Carson Group Holdings, LLC. Carson Coaching does not provide advisory services.
Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese
Social Hour With Jay Woods and Scott Brown (Ep. 5)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Social Hour is back after a summer break, and this livestream edition came loaded. Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, are joined by two technical analysis heavyweights: Jay Woods, Chief Market Strategist at Freedom Capital Markets and CNBC contributor, and Scott Brown, Founder and Strategist at Brown Technical Insights.
Fair warning: Scott was cheerfully reminded he was the (second? fifth?) choice to fill in for CNBC anchor Morgan Brennan, Sonu showed up with a Negroni, Jay was stuck with a Dunkin' iced coffee until the closing bell, and Ryan told the story of how he lost a rental car key and somehow got $200 off the bill. But in between? Plenty of substance.
They dig into the Fed's recent hike and the dot plot, with Sonu making the case that this Fed is still dovish and Jay pointing to the war, oil, and the White House as the X-factors no one can quantify. Scott and Jay walk through what the charts are saying: weakening breadth, Dow Theory divergences, key S&P 500 support levels, and a consumer discretionary sector that's cracking. They also cover the bull case for Q4 (seasonality, credit holding up, Mag 7 turning up), the AI capex boom and what would signal it's over, Bitcoin and gold setups, oil's next target, and how election-year politics could hit the AI buildout.
Key Takeaways:
- The Fed hiked: A unanimous vote, with most officials penciling in at least one more quarter-point increase by year-end
- Still dovish? Sonu argues that with core PCE forecasts up 100 bps, unemployment lower, and inflation not back to 2% until 2029, this Fed isn't really hawkish
- The X factor: Jay flags the war, oil and diesel prices, and White House volatility heading into the midterms
- Breadth is deteriorating: Only 49% of S&P 500 stocks are above their 200-day moving average, and the advance-decline line is rolling over
- Dow Theory warning: Industrials and transports aren't confirming the S&P 500, which sits just 3.5% off its highs
- Consumer discretionary under pressure: Relative weakness vs. staples and energy is a key concern
Jump to:
0:00 — Disclosures and Quick Reset
0:43 — Social Hour Returns with Drinks
5:25 — Fed Takeaways and Dot Plot Signal
12:50 — Why The Fed Still Looks Dovish
15:40 — War, Oil, and the Political Wildcard
18:37 — Breadth Weakness and Sector Stress
22:31 — Dow Theory Divergences Explained
25:49 — A Rental Car Story and Mag 7
29:52 — Bitcoin and Gold as Market Tell
34:32 — Portfolio Reality and Promo Break
44:05 — Tech Dominance and AI Capex Boom
53:17 — Oil Targets, Yields, and Election Risk
59:30 — Key Takeaways and Next Livestream
Connect with Ryan:
• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandetrick/
• X: https://x.com/RyanDetrick
Connect with Sonu:
• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sonu-varghese-phd/
• X: https://x.com/sonusvarghese?lang=en
Connect with Jay Woods:
• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jay-woods-cmt-5972679/
• X: https://x.com/JayWoods3
Connect with Scott Brown:
• LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/scott-brown-cmt-22b62891/
• X: https://x.com/scottcharts
Questions about the show? We’d love to hear from you! factsvsfeelings@carsongroup.com
Investment advisory services are offered to CWM LLC, SEC Registered Investment Advisor. This reporting is for informational purposes only as intended for an audience of financial professionals that should not be copied or reconduced without the consent of CWM LLC. Guest presenters of our show are not affiliated with CWM LLC. Opinions expressed by these presenters may not be representative of CWMLLC.
SPEAKER_02Sona, we took the summer off, but we're back. We are back with the uh live stream edition of Social Hour. And we've got some big guests, but I'll go to them in a second. Sony, what first things first, what are you drinking? What do you have?
SPEAKER_05I made myself a Negroni. I got inspired by those pictures you put out there. I I don't need to know who made them for you and how it was made, but you know, it's like, oh, those drinks look a little fancy. I do want to see your straw though, so I want to find out what you're drinking.
SPEAKER_02I'll just drink with my little finger in the air. How's that sound? I don't know. Um, yeah, I've got my Dietrich whiskey. Here it is. I'll start pouring a little Dietrich whiskey. Bur brewed right here in Dayton, Ohio. I live in Cincinnati, but it's southwestern Ohio. So I have a question on that. I have to ask you a question. Okay, we'll get there. Let's get to um the guests first. Uh, Mr. Jay Woods and Scott Brown are joining us. Jay, I guess we'll start with you. We love titles around here. So let's do your title. And you have anything you at the NYSE. Where are you right now, Jay?
SPEAKER_06I I I am uh across the street from the NYSE. Uh it's still working hours, so I did bring a drink, but is my go-to, my energy, my fuel, my Dunkin' iced coffee. Is it Iris stuff? We'll never know. Compliance uh is watching as well. So uh I'm gonna wait until that closing bell and then I'll hit happy hour capital grill and then we'll marinate some ice cubes as the great art Art Cassian used to say.
SPEAKER_02I mean, you and I were just a Capitol Grill last week, so I know where that is. There's a tricky step. You told me why there's a tricky little step when you go from one character. Yeah, it's looking for a lawsuit. I don't know.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, well, they that's when you can tell who's had too much to drink. When they they miss that.
SPEAKER_02And well, I mean, I was stone cold sober, and I'm the one falling in there because I didn't know that step was coming. So it happened, it happened. Uh, and we're also joined by Morgan Brennan. No, no, it's not Morgan Brennan, it's not Morgan Brennan, it's Scott Brown. So we're supposed to have Morgan, and Scott I worked with Scott for a long time. No, no, Scott gets it. Scott's my buddy. We worked a long time together. We started at LPL Financial the same day, so we're connected. And we originally had Morgan, just some stuff popped up with CNBC, and she couldn't make it, unfortunately. That's how it goes. She's traveling this week, I think. But the reality, I said, Hey Scott, you want to join? I said, You know, you're not as good as Morgan. And Scott goes, you know what? There's no one more disappointed that Morgan's not joining than I am, but I guess I'll do it. So, Scott Brown filling in for Morgan. How are we doing, Scott?
SPEAKER_00I'm good. I'm good. Thanks for having me, even if I was your second choice.
SPEAKER_02We asked like four other people, and everybody said no. So we're not even the same. I thought the list was I gave you a list of ten. I I know nobody wanted to do it. No, no, you were the second. I swear, Scott, you were the first one we reached out to. We were kind of in a time crunch. I said, Oh, Scott will say yes. He now, you don't even go on, you know. Um, yeah, but no. So uh so Scott, what's your official title before we get into this stuff?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I'm the the founder and strategist at Brown Technical Insights, uh, which is me, can be found on uh Substack, but I provide research to anybody who subscribe if you're if you're on here, but mostly uh financial advisors and try and help them make better active decisions for themselves and their clients. Uh and Sona, you're a man after my own art. I was gonna go Negronies, so I've got a spaghetti here. I was like, if I start drinking Negronies at three o'clock, you know, we may it may get a little aggressive by the end of this and it might not make it to dinner, but um I mean Scott, you are your own compliance though.
SPEAKER_02Like you don't mean the word the rest of us. Yeah, no, we're not worried about that. No, we lost the proof. You can say whatever you want to say. You're you are the boss. Um, all right, Sonu, let's start. What do you want to start talking about, Sonu?
SPEAKER_05I was gonna ask you if you actually like the I do you drink the Dietrich whiskey because it is your namesake, or do you actually is it good? Do you like you like it?
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's good. No, yeah, I mean, here it is. It's it's it's tasty. I mean, yes, obviously, the fact it says Dietrich whiskey is I mean, sure, but no, it's pretty tasty, and I literally only drink it when we do this. So I haven't had any for a couple months because we did take the summer off. But the plan, everybody, is we're gonna do one of these, you know, either the last Friday or third to last Friday holidays and stuff, but we're gonna do these uh the rest of the year. So what's my math? So new October, November, December. So we're gonna have three more um social hours um as well.
SPEAKER_05So I the next one is a Halloween special, so October 30th.
SPEAKER_02So definitely. We gotta really we're going AI, we're going deep into AI.
SPEAKER_05AI and China, AI and China.
SPEAKER_02But today we talk about markets. Dress up as AI and China. Try not to get uh canceled. I gotta be careful on that one.
SPEAKER_06But uh well, hopefully your AI does a better job of making your guests look a little better than what you did to us on that AI promotion. I loved it. I thought I don't know who that was a picture of, but I I was thinking of maybe doing something with my teeth. Never. No, I'm not touching them. Uh that that was scary, but uh funny, very funny. I'll give you that.
SPEAKER_02AI's got a long way to go, but it was I thought it was good. I thought it was good. Um, Sona, do we want to start with the Fed? Sono loves some of the Fed guys. Maybe let's rip the bandit off the biggest.
SPEAKER_05Let's keep the Fed. I just generally I want to find out from both these guys. I mean, you know, we have part of my bulls out here. No, it's kidding. I'll I'll kick it off. Um are you guys bullish now? What do what do you what are you looking at? Uh bullish.
SPEAKER_06I thought you're not supposed to fight the Fed. I don't understand the bullish sentiment uh when we still have some serious inflation concerns. And yes, we can break down inflation into various parts. And well, you know, obviously it's it's gas, it's the war, diesel fuel, and what that trickle-down effect will have on the economy. But first and foremost, he stepped up to the plate, 12-0 unanimous vote, approved independence. I thought that was very important. Uh he has been very telling in his fact that I want to fight inflation. We're still going to that mandated 2% gold. That has not changed. So to that, you want to say thank you. Uh the rest of the speech, he doesn't really give you much to lean on. He does not give forward guidance. Uh, he does not give his own dot. And to me, the dot plot was the telling thing because we had 16 of 18 dots that see a quarter point raise between now and the final meeting of the year. That's two meetings. So four of those officials said two hikes, so hike, hike. Um it uh it has got me troubling, but I think he said all the right things geopolitical concerns, uh the trends are starting to go the other way. And then let's remember why did we cut rates in the first place? Unemployment. And what has happened with unemployment? It's stabilized, and so now they can go the other way. Um I didn't suspect the market would sell off as much as it did, then I didn't suspect us to rally so much the next day. Um, this is a very confusing market, and I can't wait to get into that aspect of things as we continue to have our beverages along the way.
SPEAKER_04I guess we are going to talk about the Fed, but I I have my own thoughts. We'll get to it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so do I mean listen, guys? Um I want you guys to talk because once he starts, like it just it doesn't end. He just keeps going. So I want Scott to talk a little bit before we turn Sony up once he drinks a couple drinks, and you know, it's uh anyway. So, Scott, you have a mustache. How long's that been going on?
SPEAKER_00Uh, it's it's it's been around for a minute. I guess not long enough to update the uh the headshot.
SPEAKER_02But there you go. See, on social media, I never see it. That's why I didn't know.
SPEAKER_05It wasn't in the AI generated picture that writes.
SPEAKER_00Is that real? Is that a real mustache? I could have added it, but yeah. No, um, I'll just say on the Fed, you know, my biggest takeaway was actually last Friday. Um, you know, I can't remember what it was. Did we get the jobs or the inflation print, but whatever it was. What was interesting is to me at least was Fed Fund futures were at like 60% odds of a Fed hike after the print. They pretty much moved up to 85, but the market actually rallied and it almost kind of seemed to be telling me this market kind of need, you know, it wants to see the long end calm down. It need it was basically saying it almost needed a hike. Obviously, they can go too far. That's the history of the Fed, that's what everybody always worries about. We saw in 2022, but they kind of had to do something. So I actually think the reaction could have been um, you know, maybe worse if they didn't hike.
SPEAKER_02Interesting. Now, before we let Sony just unload and we all just get drunk by listening because he's gonna talk for a while. Scott, um, do you and Jay know each other? Um, everyone knows you guys are CM. Do you guys ever met before? You ever crossed paths?
SPEAKER_03We know each other. There's no doubt.
SPEAKER_00I remember you know, I don't make it to a lot of the big things, like the CMT Symposium back in DC. I saw him speak. Uh, but this is the first time we've ever really met.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I'll be at the uh CMT Symposium in D. Well, Bethesda, Maryland, not necessarily DC. Uh October, where's my calendar? It's coming up. Uh, September 29th. I think I'm speaking on the 30th. Uh, but it's uh two and a half night extravaganza in good old Bethesda, Maryland.
SPEAKER_02Where else would you want to have a let's promote the Tampa one? There's one in Tampa the second week of Decem of January. I was itching maybe go down. Scott, I know you're in Charlotte. Maybe why why should why should Scott go down to Tampa in January? What's the what's that one about?
SPEAKER_06Well, the Tampa one is gonna be on my birthday, so you should come down, bring gifts, please. It would be nice. January 13th, uh, 2027. That seems ages away. Uh, but last year, the Tampa group, uh, it was a pack house. Uh, Kathy Wood came to speak, not a technician, but she respects the technical community. It was fun to have her there. Um, and it just these events are just great because just because we look at lines on a chart, and I'm obviously being very, you know, uh obtuse about that comment, uh, we we all see different things and we all look at different indicators, and you and I are not gonna agree as we go farther along on this show, which is very rare, by the way. Um, but we we look for different signs that the market's giving us, and to have those great minds in one room and to hear some of the presenters like a David Keller, uh Ralph I Kampura was there, uh Dan Russo is gonna be in Bethesda. I haven't seen him speak, Mark Newton, Katie Stockton. Um, and a lot of our young up-and-coming CMTs, I am on the board, and my goal is to bring younger voices to the table and to really uh diversify this community uh on an age base more than anything, because we have too many old people like myself, and I want to hear what some of the younger people are saying. So, Tampa, great place to have it because the weather is perfect, it's in January. And um, you know, we have some bigger events planned and more regional events. I don't know if we have anything in Cincinnati, Ohio, uh, but if there's a group of technicians, uh, we can do something. So new Chicago, big area. Um, yeah, I've been out there a few times, and uh give me a reason to come. We're let's do Indianapolis and go to St. Elmo's. We talked about that. Uh one more Jay.
SPEAKER_02I don't want to I'm I'm gonna talk in code because I don't want to give something away if it's like in secret. You did give me some updates on the CMT leadership coming up. Are you allowed to talk about that? Or would you?
SPEAKER_06Oh, yeah. Um yeah, there's they're gonna like there it always changes every year. We we have new leadership, and uh uh I can't really divulge anything, but I'll be more involved. Let's just talk about that.
SPEAKER_02Jay might be more involved. We'll leave it there, but that'll be that'll be good.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, and it's not what I want. Uh, but it's the organization's near and dear to my heart. I have no time for this. I teach at Fordham University. Uh CNBC takes some of my time. Um, I have a family. I I I'll see them eventually uh someday. Uh but uh yeah, no, the CMT, anyone that can come to these events, I I highly recommend getting involved, just showing up uh because we have a lot of fun. And so new's been to the one in New York.
SPEAKER_05And uh yeah, I was gonna say that you know I enjoy these, and at some point I may lobby you guys since you seem to have the poll around the CMT guys, CMT people for an honorary CMT. If you guys do hand those out for like an hour, hang out with you guys.
SPEAKER_06I mean, you would think that test is a nightmare from hell, and you have to take it and pass it and then get sponsored.
SPEAKER_05We're almost 50 years old. I'm done with tests.
SPEAKER_06That's what I said when I took it, too.
SPEAKER_02Uh no, yeah, yeah, you gotta take the test. I mean, no one will want to sponsor you though, Sunny. Sony, that's a problem, you know.
SPEAKER_06That'll be tough finding sponsors for Sony.
SPEAKER_02All right, well, let's rip that band-aid off. Sony, you've had two days to think about it, 48 hours. Was the Fed hawkish, dovish, somewhere in between? What's your uh spiel? And everybody, let's give Sony like five minutes. Sony a five. No, no, I may end up taking five minutes, but uh I actually should take a sip first.
SPEAKER_05No, yeah, exactly. Um, we just published something on our website on our blog, Carson Group.com/slash research, and literally the title of it was the this Fed is still really dovish. Okay, and this goes back to Jay. You mentioned last year they made 75 basis points of cuts, insurance cuts, because they thought the labor market is jittery, they were jittery probably more than the labor market was, but set that aside, right? And of course, all this is before Bosch came in. You rewind to June of last year. At that time, they weren't that worried about the labor market. They think, okay, rates were at 4.4 percent, the policy rate. They thought maybe we'll do one more cut, two more cuts this year. This is 2025, another one in 2026, peace, you know, inflation will go down, all of that, right? So it's interesting to compare the dot plot as of September versus 15 months back. What's happened? GDP growth has been revised up from 1.6% to 2.3 percent for 2026. The core PC has gone from 2.4% to 3.4%, 100 basis points above what they thought inflation would be for 2026 relative to 15 months ago. The unemployment rate has gone down from 4.5 to 4.1 percent. Now, after that, what have they done? They made 75 basis points of insurance cuts. Not a single member of the FOMC, well, 18 of them. We don't know what Wars thinks. He doesn't want to give put a dot in. Not a single one wants to take away the entirety of the insurance cuts that they made last year. And unemployment has gone down, insurance inflation's gone up, core PC. There's no now, they're saying it's 2029 before insurance inflation gets back to the 2% target. What's the bet by next year? This time it'll be like 2030, right? Yeah, I mean it may be 2050, and they'll be saying, Oh, by 2054, inflation's gonna go back to 2%, right? So I think this will look really dumbish. And Ergo, I think all the quote-unquote hawkish talk, yes, don't fight the Fed, but don't fight the Fed if they're hawkish. I don't think they're hawkish at all, given forget our estimates of what the economy is doing, their own estimates of what the economy is doing. So, anyway, that's the camp out. I didn't take five minutes, by the way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and Sona, how long was your blog today? Was it 2,000 a word? It was huge. I shortened it. It was about 1230. I was like, about five minutes to go through it, but yeah. Well, Jay, so let's uh push back. I mean, we'll let's have some fun. What do you what do you think, Jay? You kind of what's your take?
SPEAKER_06Listen, yeah, that's great factual data, but there's an X factor that no one can quantify. And this is this is the biggest struggle for me. Uh, it is the White House. Um, the White House, if you haven't noticed, can be volatile at times. And in fact, there's a headline running across my screen. Trump is banning MSN now, CNN, and political from the White House. He can lash out. And this war continues. And I don't see an easy way out of it. And I try not to mix my politics. Not that this is a political thought, this is the reality of it. We are at war. We are seeing oil spike and diesel prices spike. It is having an impact. Um it's an election year.
unknownUh-huh.
SPEAKER_06And now we're in a period where we have no earnings until officially JP Morgan. Yes, we have Micron and Nike and Costco next week, and I know these things, but the big ones don't start until October 13th. This is the low on the market in September, um, where uh we are at an impasse where I could see a little bit of fear and a washout come to this market. Now, getting back to the Fed, uh look, the Fed officials think we're gonna go a little bit higher. And uh I I figure we have one more hike, it'll probably be in December. Um, I don't think they're gonna get the data. Uh there's no quick fix to this war. My God, if he tweets out war is over and we have a resolution, then then all bets off. We're we're going to 8,000. This is great. But um that X factor, uh, the volatility of the White House, and then I go back to 2018 when the midterms happened. And after the midterms, he did a lot of crazy stuff. Uh, we started a trade war with China. Well, now we have Canada and Europe that we're fighting with. You know, I thought they were our allies, maybe I'm wrong. Um, and strange things are happening. Now I cannot predict, and I don't want to go and be this you know, black cloud and look for this black swan event, but I am troubled by the consistent pattern of reckless self-inflicted wounds on the economy. Um, we do buy those dips, and I think we're gonna get a great dip to buy. And and I am bullish secularly. I think the economy, the earnings, we can't fight that. But this X factor, given the seasonal timing, given the lack of earnings, uh, is gonna kind of put the Fed on the back burner and they're gonna be under the microscope because I don't see a quick resolution to this price you know problem we have with oil and diesel right now.
SPEAKER_05I don't disagree with that, actually. I I I completely sort of agree with that. I think this is uh it's a different question. Okay, is that sort of priced in? But set that aside, I don't disagree. I think this inflation problem because of the war, the tariffs, I think the AI bottlenecks, all that, I think that continues. I think rates should maybe be if they really wanted to tap down on inflation, rates should probably be six percent. They don't, that's great. We overweight equity, so I'm not complaining for now. But anyway, Scott, what do you think? I'll you know, to bring Scott in.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think I can kind of play both sides here. So, like super tactically in our models, I'm recommending a neutral allocation. Uh, you're just seeing things break down. We're at exactly 60% equity is in our balanced model. Um, there's just, I mean, there's definitely some problems. We've seen breath really kind of collapse, and as of this recording, there's no real signs that we're we're not quite the wash-out territory, but there's no real signs um that it's improving yet either. Consumer discretionary really, really looks rough, especially in relative terms. You can usually pick apart each some of these companies. How much does this really reflect the real economy? Things like restaurants, but um, especially this last move up in oil. When we broke through 93, you saw a lot of areas of discretionary that were holding up really well finally buckle things like the hotels. Um, you know, really. I think I tweeted out something and I got like picked up by like Michael Badnik, but now like top-ticked it. I was like, look how good the travel and leisure ETF is, and then it just boom, it like collapsed. And I had time like vice.
SPEAKER_02I reached out to Scott and said, I don't know if you listen to Animal Spirits, they just cited you, you know, and and sure enough, we top-ticked it. Go figure, go figure.
SPEAKER_00Straight down um sense, but it's it's a little bit of a change of character from a lot of stocks that were doing pretty well. So I do have some concerns. That said, I think there's a lot of reasons to think it this should be a buying opportunity. I I want to see the signs that were there, but you look at fourth quarter seasonality, things get very, very bullish. The fact that credit's still holding up, the fact that Brett peaked with the index before major top, typically Brett peaks well before the index, not on the same day. So I think there's a lot that suggests routine correction more so than into the bull market. Uh, but I'm a little bit cautious tactically.
SPEAKER_05Can I share a chart on that consumer discretionary? This is. I hope I'm doing this right. Don't turn the whole thing off, Sonny. Or don't share a part of my screen. I'm supposed I'm not supposed to share. I'm excited to watch this. What's gonna happen here? All right. Hopefully, you guys can see that.
SPEAKER_02This is uh Todd's goodness, it worked unbelievable. Todd Stone.
SPEAKER_05I'm in Todd Stone's chart everywhere.
SPEAKER_06I'm attributed, he presents all the time.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, like this is so that Todd doesn't come and sue me and you know he's getting his attribution. But Scott, to your point, like this chart nicely shows of consumer discretionary in staples as a percentage of the SP 500 has gone down significantly. So part of me is like, does it even matter?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um, I mean, again, it's always one of those like, so do the restaurant stocks really reflect places that you actually want to eat and and things like that. But I think when you see as a group and especially equal weight discretionary versus equal weight staples, you know, that ratio is hitting a three-month low this week. Staples have been terrible for forever. We should at least be able to do better than that. I would say that's a a little bit of a concern. And then you even just look at discretionary versus energy, it's just been a pretty clear thing, and energy is you know really inflicting its pain uh and actually that ratio kind. looks like it wants to break out in favor of energy.
SPEAKER_05And on that, Jay, uh actually I'll show this. I think I have a sector chart here. I mean this shows sector performance in July. Kind of it's not you know like top that's not where the top was anything. But I want to focus on industrials and I want to ask you a question about like industrials underperforming recently. And please for the life of me I have no idea what DAO theory is. So maybe you can explain that to me and explain this whole thing you have going on with our friend JC Peretz as well.
SPEAKER_06Oh yeah well we we agree in principle the importance of Dow theory but it is an outdated term. It's it's basically tracking the industrials and the transportations the things that make and the things that take this goes back to Charlie Dow 1908 and when they are making new highs together it's confirming a bull market. It's not an index index it's not a tradable thing. It's just giving you the general consensus of the trend now the transportation's a little whacked out because of Avis symbol C A R uh having a mean like day and causing uh a rally and then a correction that throws off the charts but we are seeing divergences and when the transports start to come in usually the things that take and then the things that make start to follow each other and we're seeing some weakness in good old Dow Theory. Now Dow Theory being outdated a lot of people go well you should have the semiconductors not the industrials and we use the Dow which has more tech in it than it's ever had before but what we're seeing now is we're starting to see these charts roll over and I'm seeing that in a lot and then going back to your last chart yes the staples don't make up a lot of the index what does let's focus on the semiconductors let's focus on the XLK these are charts that are not giving us you know the warm fuzzies inside and they look like they are at a point where they may be toppy if not topping. We've seen rotation within the sector of technology where they hated those software names now they love them and the semiconductors they were leading now they're lagging. It's all about cyber by the way the cyber charts are my favorites um but the things that are going to lead this market right now you know Dow Theory is starting to roll over um I am writing uh I'm still in the process for next week's newsletter depending on where the SP 500 closed we're this is a classic bull bear battle over the near term uh we are dancing around the 50 day moving average holding on to a support level around 7600 and every time we rally we're making a lower high so we're trending down this was the week it looked like it broke down after the Fed and then we got back. So as a technician this is driving me crazy. So you look at the weight of the evidence and we're seeing the A D line breaking down. We are seeing breadth deteriorate stocks under the 200 day moving average now in the SP 500 at 49% as we're taping this so we're seeing the market weaken it's bending not breaking I think we are in the process of hopefully getting a quick flush out and resetting the dial and then we finish quarter four strong but when I talk Dow Theory that is the one thing that's got me a little nervous because Dow Theory is not confirming uh that we are just three and a half percent off all time highs in the SP 500 and it's got me concerned.
SPEAKER_02So two weeks ago I was the one in a Twitter war with Morgan Stanley if you heard anything about that I shared a chart back in April that was viral and they they they had my Twitter closed and it was a bunch of drama but you know what Calmerheads prevailed and they freed me and then threw in the towel yeah they threw in the towel white flag but then Jay you were in a little bit of a Twitter war. So I have a quick story. I think this is kind of fun Scott I want your take on Mag 7 I know you got one you mentioned Avis. Now I used a rental car from Enterprise a couple weeks ago took my daughter moved her to college I brought the car drove it up I let's see what I do I drove with my wife to state college and I took the rental car back. I got a one-way rental car from state college since then my wife stayed a little longer to help Susanna long story short that night I had to go see my son play um a football game so I said let's take the uh let's take the rental car I return it tomorrow take the rental car up there get there then when I get back to the car the car won't start I'm like wait a minute I don't have the keys like literally the car drove the whole way there somehow I don't know how I think I put the keys on the hood and I think I literally just lost the keys keys were gone it was it was it was it wasn't good. I'm like you've got to be kidding me so I get like an Uber back and I'm stressed it's the first day of school the next day I get this car parked in a parking lot is clearly not my spot I call Avis they call a tow truck all this stuff they take it to the Cincinnati airport the next day all this stuff and I'm like well this is going to cost me a lot because I lost the keys the car got towed da da da da da hope what I'm about to say doesn't come back and bite me but I'm I'm friendly with everybody so please don't report me on this a Enterprise Enterprise called me and said we heard you had some trouble with the car. I was like yeah yeah I wouldn't start they go wouldn't start we're gonna take $200 off your bill they actually gave me the car cheaper because the car wouldn't start I'm the dumb you know what that lost the keys but hey I got out of that one so that's my story about a rental car. So maybe that's why transports aren't doing well that's why maybe everyone listening to this is going to use that trick you know just turn me in just turn me in please please don't turn me I thought it was kind of funny looking back I think I'm gonna pay a thousand dollars and I got out of it. All right Scott you do incredible work I read your stuff like whenever you post it all the time I followed you forever you help financial advisors you help small investors help anybody um you you you share real time action you know I know we pontificate about the Fed and stuff I what I like about you you just kind of said here's what's going on you shared a cool chart I'm pretty sure I retweeted it mag 7 is starting to turn up I mean like right I mean what happens if mag 7 comes back finally well I mean I think that's your your bull case for the um for the fourth quarter um yeah I don't have that chart with me um but it's basically the ratio the mag 70 purchase 500 just in the past like week or so we've broken about a year long downtrend line up above the 200A is it a screaming uptrend um no but it's you know it's not it's interesting and it's real improvement from a big group that was lagging um but the one I do have and I think it's kind of speaks for itself here hopefully this is shows up um there it is you're good it's there yeah it's this one I mean the SD 500 as Jay mentioned you've got this kind of downtrend line and you've arguably had it for longer in the cues but if we can just hold up here in the cues I mean that's a call it a base call it inverse head and shoulders pattern I mean up above 730 735 on the cues um you know that really would be a pretty powerful technical breakout so I think if we can hang in here I mean this has been a rough seasonality but we basically just chopped sideways we get into the bullish seasonal period you know at least those two things would certainly align uh with a lot of runway for the Qs let me dive in um so tech I mean Bitcoin's perking up it had the huge rally consolidating beneath previous peak Jay and or Scott anybody having a take a take on Bitcoin here um I think uh as a technician the risk reward is something that uh favors somebody taking a shot here uh you know we we made a higher low we broke a major downtrend we're trading above 81000 as we're taping this up 5000 today um you know it's one of those you buckle up and um you know I'll I'll risk you know 13,000 points to the downside for you know a reward uh in a year and a half this getting back and making new highs so um it's an asset class I don't really follow we don't touch it here at freedom but you know the only way I followed is technically and technically it's poised for somebody to take a shot here no doubt. So I'll just say this much. So Son and I along with Barry uh Gilbert uh on our team and Grant Engelbart we manage you know maybe eight nine billion dollars give or take depending on the day and Sonu and our tactical models what are we about 1.2 to 1.5% Bitcoin a little bit right yeah not a lot but enough that if it moves I mean so we I'm not like a huge Bitcoin bull I don't want to be but like we you know we look at it like a diversifier and I look at that chart and I think it's I think it wants to go higher.
SPEAKER_00Scott, do you have a take on Bitcoin or any maybe let's just say you know that that world uh in general crypto in general no bitcoin's the main one that I follow so I'm mostly interested in you know the big ones that at least have an ETF that you can invest easily in them. But on actual Bitcoin it's about 83000 is the middle of that trough the way I see it we get up above there we're at 80 in change as of this reporting it's like a major double bottom that looks like it measures back well above 100,000.
SPEAKER_05Why we talk about Bitcoin what about gold?
SPEAKER_00Yep you know it's interesting um actually we were talking in the in the pre-show one of the only two um you know sectors that are up on the week it's technology and healthcare like barely the two asset classes leading this week are gold and bitcoin so if you're looking for a message on the Fed um I think that's interesting. Gold's kind of neutral trend right near a flat 200 day moving average we came into this week at a big support zone and it it's held and bounced um so I think maybe that long kind of down draft that we saw it it looks like it might be over we might have a chance for some more upward momentum.
SPEAKER_02What do you think Jay gold?
SPEAKER_06Yeah uh I got long gold two weeks ago uh and then it immediately reversed but it broke an intermediate downturn uh downtrend uh we had a nice run a full classic flagging pattern if you will and I'm seeing indicators giving me buy signals that MACD gave us a buy signal about a month ago um stochastics buy signal RSI it never really got oversold but uh from a technical point of view uh I think this and Bitcoin uh you can never really get that correlation and I've never tried to correlate Bitcoin with anything I just treat that on its own but I I think gold right here um risk reward again as we measure these things I think the worst of it is over and um we had a nice bottoming process and let's see if we can get back above uh what am I looking at this uh 50-week moving average on a weekly chart around 4409, 410 and I I think it's smooth sailing so uh it's not a bad place to be um given the sell-off that we've seen and the the bottoming formation that I think we've finally put in.
SPEAKER_02Sona love you're taking a second. So Sona and I can mention manage a lot of money like we do have a little bit of gold in some of our strategic models and our tactical models. So strategic thing three to five years. We've owned that the whole time tactical yeah you get a little cute here and there but we did add some more recently I mean that's interesting that Bitcoin and gold were both up this week I guess it's true but you know to put a bow on it Sonu you know we've got some we probably can't mention exact ETFs we have a little more gold than Bitcoin.
SPEAKER_05Yeah a little more gold than Bitcoin but we've got some ETFs to do some stacking you know just leave it there um and those those have helped our models this week what's your take on Bitcoin andor gold sonu I mean I've to Jay's point I've I've struggled with the correlation sometimes bitcoins looked like a software stock sometimes I mean we were on the compound I remember Michael Batnik showed us hey guys isn't this software and then you know it's not doing software type stuff after that right sometimes it's correlated with gold so I think just separate that right bitcoins it's you know it's a risk on asset I'll put it that way it's a risk on asset you know for the most part and the gold is interesting because again not to tie everything back to the Fed but I will you always tie everything back to the Fed Sony seriously it's it's snowing outside oh my goodness it's because of the Fed look if you think two years ago gold had that was it two years ago no last year last year gold had that big rally after August after Jackson after Jackson Hole massive rally after Jackson Hole and then when did it stop? Somewhere in Fed and I would argue that's when we started worrying about inflation right after Jackson Hole again tying this to the Fed you can argue yes or that's a good thing bad thing. But I think you know it's a sign of the Fed was dovish last year in the face of elevated inflation inflation really became a problem let's say after a fed in March and then gold tanked because suddenly everyone was like you were pricing in two cuts for 2026 and now we're suddenly pricing in hikes that's a big shift right you get a more hawkish Fed like I'll put it this way if I thought the Fed was going to raise rates to six percent seven percent in the team I'd say we we should get out of gold right right but the Fed being easy right I think that's a positive for gold um the fact gold's up this week maybe is true.
SPEAKER_02So Scott uh a little bit about Scott and I just kind of fun personal stuff so we started LPL financial on the same day right Scott I guess what would have it been um January 16th 2016 it was early early January of 2016 yeah it was 2016 and then I I I hit my seven year itch and was ready for something new and thank God I did I've been working with Sunday every day since then it's been a blast and I left and Scott made it about a week and then Scott said I'm out I can't do without Ryan is that pretty much what happened Scott you just couldn't do without me but it's just our memory not one week he called this Ryan or we're just gonna work alone uh and luckily work alone has worked out pretty well uh celebrating our four year anniversary I think literally the very first Monday morning playbook went out tomorrow four years ago. Oh congratulations and that's actually why I was going to go with this next you left four years ago I left four years and you just hit your four years I guess we'll call it anniversary again I've read probably every report you've ever done and you you're awesome. I mean I I probably gotta be careful how much I promote you but let's just say there's a reason you're on the show. Scott promote us one more time promote your product one more time and tell everybody with the word so new they get what like a free week a free month?
SPEAKER_00How's that work for calling I've actually got a code if you'll let me share the QR code now let's do it let's share the code for for your stuff let's do it all right I'll share it but yeah you can uh use this um QR code and get uh 20% off your first year of Brown technical insights or you can just go to um brown insights uh com it's there on Substack but that'll take you to it and get a free um you know get a free trial whatever you want to do but um four reports a week I'm out here covering you know the top down technical strategy uh we do have equity research as well and uh hard stock picks on what we call the blue chip hot list with entries and exits so uh hopefully a little something for people that are tuned into this at 3 30 eastern time on a Friday.
SPEAKER_02And I'll just say you do a lot of individual individual equity stuff too which we don't really dive into but if someone's interested in individual equity Scott you're all over that too. So Jay, good stuff Scott. So so Jay, uh you're you what do you do all day?
SPEAKER_06I mean you're on TV, you're flying around you're doing stuff you have a newsletter you have a newsletter as well I can't promote paired with the QR code for my newsletter. I I don't like it. You know what send me five $50 and I'll give you my tweets 10 minutes before they go out to the rest of the world. Oh wait no you can't do that. Oh I'm sorry I wonder what that was a reference to but uh no um I write a weekly newsletter for Freedom Capital Markets. If you go to freedomcapmktts.com you can find a sign up for my uh newsletter you go to my LinkedIn follow me there uh there's a tab right there for my newsletter I'll pin it after this um yeah we have well over 5,000 people the feedback has been great it's a perfect table setter this is Sam Rose comment so I I should put this you know the perfect table setter for your weekly updates um where we review what we're gonna be watching next week that's why I knew Micron Costco uh Nike next week Nike by the way perfect example of a long-term downtrend which I will teach at Fordham University I teach uh spring semester every year to graduate school students at the Cabelli School of Business Go Rams um and so that's part of my day uh representing freedom talking to clients uh another big part I teach introduction to technical analysis and market behavior so uh it's it's a passion project yeah yeah it's a passion project uh the students uh have been phenomenal uh a few of them have gone on and taken uh the cmt levels and uh it's it's one of the more exciting things I've done. I hate them when they complain about A minus, I'll be honest. But um overall it's been it's been a joy. And then uh as Ryan knows we're both CNBC contributors uh and that has been uh one of the greatest honors of a lifetime being able to uh be a part of the team that I watched growing up my whole life uh and uh you know being that voice from the floor hence I'm in my smock I'm on call uh you know whenever something interesting happens uh you know Brian or Kelly will put me on Power Lunch uh uh you know Ryan and I are part of the morning call crew uh and Morgan Brennan yes Scott filling in admirably uh you know was not able to join us after all but uh she's uh been somebody that I I love working with and um she just did a great piece on uh 9-11 and the recovery after uh 9-11 uh which we celebrated 25 years ago which is hard to believe it's been 25 years since that uh happened so great I mean you you helped me become a contributor.
SPEAKER_02I mean hopefully I did it on my own but you definitely connected some dots for me and you helped so many people in this industry and Jay I mean I every time I turn on TV you're you're there you're doing something so I love seeing that I will say also I love seeing we have close to 2,000 people following this live on at my X stream right now I know more people on YouTube in different places. So thank you to everybody out there. Guys it's shocking how fast this goes we got about 20 minutes. Jay one more of a fun one then we'll get more into stuff the last 15 minutes like I've given this story before I'll do it one more time I was on with Soli live in New York's Brian Solva I used to back in COVID I did that evening show with him. I forget what it was called but I did an evening show all the time and I was first time in live with him probably 24 and I was in that big room you know where you do the the uh power lunch show and I don't know why I said it but it's just you know put a put a mic in front of me I'll say anything he said hey Ryan Dietrich it's about time you're here face to face you know been a while how you doing I said you know what Sully I'm doing good but this is the first time I've talked to you in two years while I'm wearing pants I just said it he and I he and I laughed the entire four minute hit like we couldn't we couldn't even like the whole room busted up laughing because that's just how I am give me a funny story maybe not like that but I mean live TV is live TV. The other just last week I was gonna say good morning Morgan now it's yeah you know I I I combined the word Morgan and morning on live TV it wasn't that big a deal after the fact when you do it in your head you think oh you idiot you just screwed up the word Morgan and morning but it is hard give me a funny story Jay about you maybe messing up on live tv and trust me I'm not man I I I I wish I had oh I don't want to tell these stories because I'm gonna get in trouble with the network.
SPEAKER_06It's funny this is when we leave the 2000 people watching this and we go to the bar and I will stories about you know something that happened at Power Lunch that caused me to get bumped um but uh you know pronouncing the word NVIDIA wrong and it you know canceled my next appearance on a certain show. These are things that are a little private and and delicate have I messed up on air I'm sure I have I I I mess up every other time I speak uh ask my friends. But uh there is not one thing that stands oh I I can tell you the worst call I ever made on my best appearance of all time it was future proof. Future proof Josh Brown's great event and Michael Patnik the team I got to go down there represent the firm walk around I I believe you may have been there for that one. And I had a hit with uh Tyler Matheson and Kelly Evans on Power Luncher and I did this whole charting segment and they had nothing in front of me absolutely nothing. So it was FedEx I knew it inside and out this is this is how my brain works and this is why I think I'm okay at what I do is I remember statistics, I remember charts, I see a picture of it once and it just goes into my brain and I did this whole segment of FedEx and where I thought it was going to go and then Kelly Evans goes oh my God ladies and gentlemen home he has nothing in front of him he did this and then you know earnings after the bell it was the worst call I ever made in my life and I don't remember the good calls but this thing it it it tanked I had the bullish argument the the stop loss it went through the stop loss by 20 points. Anyone that listened to me that day and bought FedEx um they they probably are throwing things go to the chat if there is one yell at me that's fine um but um being in front of a screen and charting with no charts was a scary but one of the coolest things I've ever done and you know and then I had this function background they're future proof what what what's better than that so um I have oh and then you know back in the day Yahoo Finance I've been on the telestrator and and it just doesn't work and you know live TV you just gotta roll with it. And thankfully I can chart with like my my hands and we we made it work uh that was Jared Blickray at the time maybe Ali canal Ashonda Smith I'm not sure but um you know live TV you never know what's gonna happen.
SPEAKER_02Jump in at one second here Sony you do live TV and it happens I mean it it it happens and again uh you know get serious for a second I mean listen we go on morning call all the time Jay I'm on once a week you're on once a week I mean we're huge fans of Morgan yeah it's it's it's it's a great show it's awesome so definitely if everybody out there listening can check out the morning call with Morgan Brandon in the morning along with all the other programming on CNBC it's it's great but Morgan's amazing and um it's a really cool show early in the morning if you can wake up and check that out.
SPEAKER_05All right Sonu we've got I don't know 10 or 15 what else want to talk about I don't know how you guys do early morning like I was up at four o'clock to go out to Silicon Valley over you know earlier this week and it was you know insane I had a couple of events but speaking of Silicon Valley I mean it's crazy how much you know I I have friends I met friends there prospects clients all of that right our advisors shout out to Derek Testa as well we had a few amazing events including at a winery and I don't drink wine so that was interesting who's allergic to wine you shouldn't be allergic to wine but he just whines about The bed, that's his wine. So yeah, it's his wine. It's a good one. But Scott, you put up the chart of the Q's, and you know, I think generally the sense is okay, Brett is not in a great place right now. And I'm like, does it even matter? You know, if the tech, if tech does it's all about tech in the markets, in the economy. Yes, I know Trump tweets something, something could go right, but it's all about the AI build-out, it's all about CapEx, it's all about earnings coming from CapEx. It's all about anthropic, go anthropic and open AI, how much of compute they're gonna, you know, generate. I mean, just the the Times had an article today. Anthropic saying their compute is going to increase from 1.5 gigawatts last year to five gigawatts this year to 10 next year. There's no end to the spending, and one person's spending is another person's revenue. I would could make the argument, and maybe it's because of the strong Negroni, that nothing else matters other than tech. Forget that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think that's why that uh, you know, I kind of chaired it. You know, that that's when it starts, because nothing else does matter. If the cues goes higher, I mean, it's those stocks are what make up the whole big weight of the SP 500, everything else can do a whole lot of nothing. The SP 500 is going higher. So you're right. I mean, there's definitely been some fur firming in the Mag 7. It's a pretty um divergent group. It really doesn't make a lot of sense to even refer to it as a theme. Every individual stock is kind of acting on its own. Um, but the semiconductors have stopped falling. I I don't know if I love them, but you look at like the memory names, you know, it's pretty negative on them near the top. I mean, you just saw every classic bubble sign, and they moved about 30-40 percent off the highs, and then from there, you know, I kind of said the bull case is sideways action for like a year plus. Maybe you can see the case is where the probability of that is inching up because now they're just kind of hanging in and they're just kind of chopping sideways. It kind of reminds me of what NVIDIA did in like 2023. It had its huge move and then it went sideways for like a year. The 200-day moving average got up, and then it had a whole nother leg higher. And so, again, I'm not a buyer of the semiconductors based on that, but certainly the fact that you know they aren't completely v-topping and you know, heading down 80% after a move like that um bodes well because those are still a huge weight in whether it's the Q's, the SP 500, um, and then the funders and the very top weights, you know, those are those are doing better. Not a recommendation, but you know, Apple, you know, up there near the highs, meta's been a dog, but it's improving. So yeah, nothing else does matter. Uh, we'll see it, you know. I don't know what's pressuring small caps and things like that, but they if the last 15 years have taught us anything, is this market does not need small caps or great breadth to go higher.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, and to Scott's point, where we're seeing that NVIDIA-like action, remember the DRAM stocks and that parabolic run they've got on micron, discs, they're starting to go into that nice long sideways action. I believe long-term this is constructive, but the averages are catching up. The 50 days have caught up to all of them. The 200 day is getting there. Micron still has a long ways to go, but it's what happens after these big moves, we digest them. So the sideways, and I always say this, I teach it, sideways is a direction. Neutral trends happen over time, and I think in this neutral trend, what we are having now, we are about to test a new lower end of that neutrality. Uh, and to me, that's 7200, 7250 when we look at the SP 500. Now, am I allowed to ask a question of our hosts, or is that you know, frowned upon because I am here?
SPEAKER_03Let's do it.
SPEAKER_06My question is, Ryan, I I I follow you on Twitter and we're good friends, and everyone, oh, perhaps, Ryan, he's always bullish. I that that is not true. I know that's no what is your biggest concern? Because we have pointed out some things that you know with double top and NVIDIA, Broadcom is 350 level, semi's looking uh a little. What are the things that concern you over the near term and then would change uh a long-term bullish narrative, which I am not in the camp to do, but uh what's things that's got you concerned?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, thanks for that. I mean, I was I remember going on with Morgan back in like you know, February, talking about watch out for banana peel sell-off. This is when the market's making new highs. Everybody's all you guys all bullish, and we were saying that we had the 9.1% Pikachuff correction. Um, then you know, late late March, that was the lows, and some long-term bowls were kind of throwing in the white, waving the white flag and uh throwing in the towel, and then we took off from there at a historic rally. Like right now, I mean, I've been on record with Sony on facts versus feelings, you know, saying, listen, the first half of September could be a little dicey. We're talking about the weakening breath late in August, and it's kind of playing out. I mean, I do look at the number of stocks above the 20-day 20 day moving average, we broke 20, 20 recently. I mean, that's kind of not washout material, but that's one thing we we do want to see. I mean, you're getting a little geeky with spreads. I mean, listen, the the triple C spreads are kind of concerning, it's a smaller part. I get it, triple C spreads are going up now. You triple B relative to double B high yield spreads. We're not seeing any stress. Scott talked about that probably 30 minutes ago. I mean, those things are there. I mean, I have the same worries everybody else. I mean, yields don't slow down. I mean, our base case has been inflationary growth, meaning the Fed's, I mean, Soda pointed this out in March. It was a zero percent chance of a hike this year. That's in March. That wasn't that long ago. We just got our first hike. Um, you know, so things are pretty darn hot. You know, now again, you know, is the Fed going to become super hawkish? I mean, that'd be a worry of ours as we laid out. We don't think it's quite there. Um, that 20 with last comment, the 6710 level, that's the early June peak, and it's ballparked to 50 day moving average. I looked a little bit ago, we we were above that again. So we broke it two weeks in a row, but did manage to pop up above it by Friday, assuming we don't sell off majorly here since we'll be doing this. Um, so those are the areas I'm looking at. I mean, I guess the breadth and some of the lower quality spreads are uh some of my concerns, which I mean, I'll tell you, I'm still pretty optimistic. We get a I'm not I'm not Tom Lee generational, you know, rally, but I do think the second half of September could surprise people, much like the last two years with double digit, we're not double digits, but between two and three percent gains in September. I'm still I'm still there. I mean, Sony, that's a good one too for you. I mean, you know, we've been talking about run it hot for a while. Um, what what what what does worry you from a portfolio manager point of view, thinking about how much money we run and we work with financial advisors and clients every single day? I mean, Carson Group's about to crack $70 billion. When I started, we were 20 billion four years ago. Sono we were even less. What were we when you started Sony, six or seven years ago? 10 billion? Oh, about seven, eight billion. Wow. So almost darn near darn near 10x it. Um, yeah, what worries us from a portfolio manager point of view, you think?
SPEAKER_05Look, things are running hot, and as we talk about, I think it's tech, right? The capex it's it's not the productivity growth and AI being deployed across the economy, and you know, you get a lot of diffusion of AI and productivity growth. That's all that may come. It's later, five, ten years from now, who knows, right? Now it's a capex thing. Everything's running hot if the Fed gets serious about tamping that down. Yes, I think that's a big concern. Right now, they're not. I mean, one thing I was watching, I mean, Watch doesn't say much, maybe you know, it's good and bad. I was watching to see, I was listening to, you know, is he talking about any worries related to this CapEx boom running too hot? And he didn't. In my mind, they're okay with it for now. At some point, they may not be, right? And but at that point, I'll start worrying more. But the other thing I'll connect it to breath. I don't want to see rotation. In a sense, I don't want to see breath. If I see rotation, sustained rotation for six, eight months, I'll worry that the AI boom is over. I don't want to see it. I mean, you look go back to 2000. The bull market ended now and with the benefit of hindsight in March of 2000. Look at 2000 to March of 2000 to December of 2000. We saw rotation. We saw sustained rotation. Financials are doing well, and all it wasn't just defensive sectors, and then everything just collapsed because the boom was done. It took a while for people to understand that the boom was done. So if you see sustained rotation, I would be very worried. I would say that's the end. I don't think we're close to that, right? And it's positive that we haven't heard about South Korea in the news over the last month. I mean, it goes back to both what Jay and Scott were saying. The sideways movement is sort of good, right? You don't want sustained.
SPEAKER_02Well, there is a time when so Sonu didn't sleep, he'd stay up all night just to watch the South Korean stock market. Those two stocks? Those two stocks. We have eight, we have eight minutes to go. Scott, I mean, it might be the last time you talk. You might have two more, but what else should we be watching? And what else do you want us to know about uh Brown uh technical insights?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I mean, if you want to provide the ongoing thoughts, subscribe to Brown Technical Insights, you know, do a free trial, um, check it out. I think there's there's something for everybody, but uh ultimately I try and stand on the reports that I put out every single week. I mean, I think the least sexy answer to watch is oil. Like I, you know, I mentioned back the discretionary stocks, but it just kind of seemed like that last breakout, um the market really didn't like it. And I think, yes, the Fed hyped, and we've seen yields back off, but oil's also backed off. And if you really just look, it seems like every single morning, you know, what is oil doing? Well, that's what yields are doing, and that's what the inverse of the SP futures are doing. And that it wasn't that way four or five months ago, even if it was dominating the headlines to the same extent. So, my near-term target, I mean, if you just look at the base on oil, we broke up above 93.94, the target is 112. That's basically the year-to-date highs. So it doesn't break you out, but if we were to get there, and then of course you go through 112, you can just kind of open up your imagination. You know, people are talking about $200 oil and things like that in March, and that never happened, but something uncomfortably high that nobody is gonna like probably lives on the other side of 112. So, again, don't want to play ifs, I'll play the current market, but that's certainly something that I'm watching, and I continue to like the energy stocks. They're the highs, I don't see overly aggressive sentiment. Again, construction are making 52-week lows, energy's making 52-week highs. It it's just a good looking chart, and it's been leading oil higher the whole cycle.
SPEAKER_05Actually, Jay, you mentioned, you know, I think you brought up the election thing. Do you think after the election, Trump just goes all out on Iran?
SPEAKER_06Uh, I have no idea what Trump is doing. I mean, yes, I think this is like terms. I went all out. We have no idea what he meant. Um, who knows who gets the wrath? Uh it could be us on the show for saying something somewhat negative. Who knows what the president's watching? Uh, you can't get into that. Um, I try to.
SPEAKER_05Because that could be a scenario that sends oil, I don't know, to 125 oil?
SPEAKER_06Yeah, um it escalates even more. You know what? The worst thing, boots on the ground. God forbid we escalate and we bring boots on the ground. That would be devastating to this market. Um, you know, thank God we found that soldier behind them in enemy lines because if they had one American hostage and put that on TV, the reaction would have been disastrous. And so thank God for that mission, and that gentleman got home safe. Um, so like I'm trying not to go worst case scenario. I'm trying to follow the trends, but the energy trends continue to be strong. And what has been interesting is the tenure has not spiked, it's gone slow and steady. And the days where it spikes, we get those negative reactions, it digests, it stays around 5%. The equity market continues to stay and stabilize. So that to me, uh if we get a spike where the the tenure now breaks out, because it would be a major breakout, above five percent. And I know Ryan has said we could see it go to six percent. Um the speed of which we break out could be um dramatic, could be a problem for this market. Um so energy and those stocks look great. And then they're gonna have to rebuild the infrastructure to some of these energy names once things do settle down. So I think the XOP is a great place to be. Um, and you know, uh ExxonMobil for us technicians. I I got to write about this at the end of last year, and it was, you know, pat myself on the back a little bit. It it looked like an easy call. That's the thing we're not seeing right now. Joe Fami tweeted about this. Joe Fami is a great follow. Um there aren't fat pitches right now for traders. For the trading community out there, this has been a very frustrating market. And we technicians see things where we can argue both sides of this. And I have that X factor in the back of my head where I'm trying to hide and not listen to what's going on in Washington. But the things that are happening in Washington are driving this market, they're having impacts. So you cannot, as a technician, just say, I'm just looking at the charts, I am blocking it all. No, the fundamentals matter, and uh so to me, that that's the the concerning thing. And in the election, what is the big thing that everyone agrees on? We don't want AI in our backyard. 70% Republicans, Democrats say the AI build needs to slow down. Um, no one's against AI. I mean, although it will kill us in five years, according to some people. Um, you know, it was good knowing you. We've had a good run. But um what in the Terminator references have been unbelievable lately. But the AI could hit a stumbling block, and we're seeing it in stocks with the bill. We're seeing caterpillars, but applied digital come back in. Uh stocks that have done well, the pics and shovels, are kind of, you know, giving us, I believe, I believe caterpillar long term is giving us a great entry point, but the rhetoric behind it could cause some more panic selling. Uh, and uh the politicians are gonna use this as a talking point because it will get them elected. And uh so don't leave until November 5th, right? Yeah, to November 5th. And who knows? We've seen November 5th the next day markets rally and rally strong, and that seasonally to me is is what I'm looking for. I believe we're gonna have a strong year-end rally. There's that X factor. Um, and then just uh to follow up, uh Scott, I do have something to promote. Uh, I did tweet out the link to my newsletter. If you follow me, Jay Woods and free uh at Twitter. Uh I'm on the cusp, but it Twitter is weird, by the way, and I still call it that. Yes, I know it's X. Um I I have gained and lost the same amount of followers for the last six months. I've been on the cusp of 20,000. Not that I care. Follow me, don't follow me. It doesn't matter. Uh but I do promote things there, and it's the algo is weird. I have not upticked or downticked in in quite some time. But uh at Jay Woods3 on Twitter, there's a link to my newsletter, and you can hear me uh talk about uh a lot of the things we talked about today. Uh we you can read about it uh on Sunday night when it comes out.
SPEAKER_02Well, Jay, Jay um and Scott, this was awesome. I will say what's upticked a little bit is this podcast. Thank you to everybody out there. So Sonu and I, along with our producer Podpony, who's helped us today on this uh live stream, we put a real significant effort in YouTube this year to really, really grow the YouTube channel. And I mean, literally the podcast we did last week was the second most downloaded or viewed YouTube video ever had. The last two or three, Sony, right? We've like cracked the top 10 every time. So we're really starting to find some leverage and some growth in the YouTube channel. And listen, it is what it is, as our uh friend Phil Perman would say, the higher the VIX, the higher the clicks. The VIX is boring, nothing's going on. Literally, the market's not moving. I know there's break this under the surface and the headlines, but you get your views when the market's down 10-15%. And we are hitting some incredible numbers already. So thank you to all of the listeners out there and and viewers out there of the Facts versus Feelings podcast. Um, it means a lot to Sonu and I and the Carson group that everybody keeps checking us out. It's awesome. And thank you again to Jay and Scott for joining us. Sonu, 30 seconds or so. What do you want to say? And I'll bring us home.
SPEAKER_05No, thank you, Jay, Scott. This was awesome. I follow you guys, and you know, like I don't think I'm supposed to recommend or anything like that. So, anyway, your work speaks for yourself. I'll put it that way. Right. So, you know, if you follow your work, you know, for those that follow your work, I mean, you know, you can see that, right? Yep, and yeah, to second what Ryan said, thank you all for your support. I mean, we love doing this week in, week out, facts versus feelings. It's on Apple, Spotify with video now, yes, YouTube as well, and Carson Group.com slash research. Shout out to the Carson Investment Research team as well. Thank you all for you know the charts and all everything, all the support.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I believe our next one, Sonu, is October 30th, Friday, October 30th, Halloween. We're gonna dress up. Um, we have a very special guest, uh, AI specialist. Uh Armani Carson uh set us up with a friend of his who's gonna be incredible. I don't officially announcing it yet, but we'll promote that all over the place. We're gonna dive a lot into AI in China uh on October 30th. But hey, we do these weekly, every Wednesday morning. Sign up wherever you get your favorite podcast, Facts versus Feelings means a lot to us. All right, with all of that, everyone, this again was your latest Facts versus Feelings social hour. Enjoyed it. Hopefully you had a drink or two, and let's start the weekend, everybody. So we'll see everybody next time. Again, thanks, Jay. Thanks, Scott, thanks, Sonu, and thanks to Podpony, our producer. See you right next time. Take care. Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_01Investment advisory services are offered through CWM LC, SEC Registered Investment Advisor. This reporting is for informational purpose only as intended for an audience of financial professionals who should not be copied or reproduced without the consent of CWM LLC. Guest presenters of our show are not affiliated with CWM LLC. Opinions expressed by these presenters may not be representative of CWM LLC.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.